Last Updated on October 27, 2026 by Lauren Belzer Sanford
San Diego holds a special place in my heart, though maybe not for the reasons you’d expect.
There are the childhood memories first: visits to my grandparents and my aunt and uncle, the kind of trips that stay with you long after the people at the center of them are gone. And then there’s the chapter Max and I wrote ourselves.
We moved to downtown San Diego in the fall of 2019, right after college, and right before the world turned upside down. City life wasn’t quite us, and the timing couldn’t have been harder; we were in the thick of the East Village through the strangest season any of us can remember. We stayed nearly two years before a semi-nomadic stretch in the Pacific Northwest, then landed back in Orange County in 2022.
Looking back, those years shaped something. The way I think about food, neighborhood culture, and getting to know a place through its restaurants took root in San Diego, partly out of necessity and partly because the city made it so easy to eat well. We’ve been back many times since, and the food never disappoints. This guide mixes our longtime favorites from living there, spots tied to family visits, newer finds, and a few still on my list.
My San Diego Restaurant Favorites
Best Pasta
Cesarina
Point Loma
Best Oysters & Cocktails
Ironside
Little Italy
Special Occasion
Rare Society
University Heights
Best Morning
Achilles Coffee
Downtown
The best restaurants in San Diego, from a former local, are Barbusa, Monello, and Bencotto for Little Italy pasta, Ironside Fish & Oyster for cocktails and the raw bar, Cesarina in Point Loma for fresh handmade pasta, Rare Society for a special-occasion steak dinner, Brigantine for waterfront seafood, Great Maple for brunch, and Achilles Coffee Roasters for the London Fog I ordered almost daily. For a La Jolla lunch, Lucrezia’s covered patio is lovely.
Still choosing a hotel? Here’s where to stay in San Diego, from Coronado Island to La Jolla.
Little Italy
Barbusa
Barbusa is Italian with a little more energy, festive even on a Tuesday, with a beautiful room and a menu worth repeat visits. It was one of our favorites when we lived here. Don’t skip the arancini or, if they’re on, the fiori di zucca (fried squash blossoms); I still talk about them. For pasta, the gnocchi and the lobster fusilli are standouts.
Best For: A lively Little Italy dinner, date night · What to Order: Arancini with truffle cream · Fiori di zucca · Gnocchi · Lobster fusilli
Bencotto
Bencotto is the cheese-wheel pasta restaurant: tossed tableside in a 60-pound wheel of Parmigiano Reggiano. It’s as theatrical as it sounds and tastes even better. We brought Max’s parents here when they visited. Beyond the wheel, there’s a build-your-own pasta-and-sauce menu; the Bencotto sauce, a pink pancetta sauce, is the right place to start, and the riso fritto with Bolognese dip is a must.
Best For: The cheese-wheel experience, a celebratory Italian dinner · What to Order: Riso fritto · Cheese-wheel pasta · Bencotto sauce
Ironside Fish & Oyster
Ironside became a favorite before we even moved here. I first went on a Fourth of July bar crawl through Little Italy in 2019 and worked my way through most of the cocktail menu; every single one was exceptional. We came back for lunch after moving, and the seafood matched the cocktails completely. It’s a beautiful room with a serious raw bar.
Best For: Cocktails and seafood in Little Italy · What to Order: Oysters Rockefeller · Peach and burrata salad · Any cocktail
Monello
Just across the street from Barbusa, Monello is another Little Italy institution we returned to more than once, including a dinner with Max’s parents. Order from the specialty pastas or build your own. My favorites are the tortelloni al tartufo and the saffron spaghetti with shrimp, plus the panzerotti and the cauliflower with spicy aioli to start. (The panzerotti, a Pugliese fried pastry, means a little more to me now that I’ve gotten married in Puglia.)
Best For: Pasta in a convivial room, a dinner you’ll linger over · What to Order: Panzerotti · Cavolfiori with spicy aioli · Tortelloni al tartufo · Spaghetti di zafferano con gamberi
Nolita Hall
On the edge of Little Italy’s main strip, Nolita Hall works for almost anything: brunch with the girls, cocktails before dinner, an easy date night. Behind the bar, a split-flap sign rotates quotes on top and incoming flights below, because Nolita Hall sits right under the airport’s landing path. I couldn’t stop watching it.
Best For: Drinks and brunch with friends · What to Order: Avocado bruschetta with beets (trust me) · The Lara’s Jam cocktail
Craft & Commerce
Craft & Commerce just has good energy: lively, a little quirky, with creative cocktails and a bar scene that feels local. Reserve on weekends; it’s packed. The cocktails are the draw, but the food holds its own.
Best For: Weekend drinks, a fun night out · What to Order: Anything on the cocktail menu · Brussels sprouts · The burger · Schmaltz fries
Mimmo’s
Mimmo’s earns its place because everything it does, it does well: classic, unfussy Sicilian cooking. We brought my parents here, and my dad loved it so much he’s been back on his own on business trips. That kind of loyalty says everything.
Best For: Classic Sicilian cooking, a family dinner · What to Order: Calamari fritti · Meatballs · Arancini · Baked lasagna · Campanelle with sausage · Cannoli (non-negotiable)
Downtown, Gaslamp & the Waterfront
Achilles Coffee Roasters
If there’s one place I went more than anywhere else while we lived here, it’s Achilles Coffee Roasters. The Del Rey location was next to my office, so ordering became muscle memory (I’ve also been to Park 12). My order, every time: a London Fog and the Hillcrest breakfast sandwich with a fried egg instead of scrambled. Start your San Diego morning here.
Best For: Morning coffee, a work session, the best London Fog you’ll ever have
Brigantine at Portside Pier
Brigantine is exactly where you want to be for fresh seafood with a view, right on the waterfront. It works for a relaxed lunch, a pre-show dinner (we’ve eaten here before a concert at Petco Park), or a long afternoon with a cocktail. There’s a Coronado location, too.
Best For: Waterfront seafood, pre-concert dinner · What to Order: Crispy coconut macadamia shrimp · Brig clam chowder · Macadamia-crusted mahi mahi, which always reminds me of Maui · Grilled marinated swordfish
Puesto at the Headquarters
Puesto near Seaport Village is good without any pretension, great for margaritas and appetizers, a full dinner, or Taco Tuesday, and there’s a happy hour worth checking before you go. There are locations across California, but the Headquarters has its own charm. Reserve either way.
Best For: Tacos and margaritas by the waterfront · What to Order: Potato taquitos · Filet mignon taco · Mango-limón agua fresca · The Puesto Perfect guacamole (with Parmesan; just go with it)
Rustic Root
Rustic Root is the Gaslamp’s rooftop answer, lovely by day and even better as the evening settles in. I default to sparkling rosé, but The Elder Empress (gin and sparkling wine) is a beautiful French 75 cousin.
Best For: Rooftop drinks, sunset cocktails in the Gaslamp
Beyond Downtown
Cesarina – Point Loma
Cesarina was a pandemic-era discovery. We found it when restaurants had built little outdoor patios just to stay open, ate outside on a cool evening, and were immediately smitten. The details are part of the charm: beautiful dishware and rooster pitchers you can buy to take home. Choose your fresh pasta shape and sauce, or order from the house favorites. The paccheri vodka with scampi is the classic; I’m always drawn to the pomodoro fresco.
Best For: Fresh handmade pasta, a charming neighborhood feel · What to Order: Paccheri vodka and scampi · Pomodoro fresco · Any fresh shape that calls to you
Great Maple – Hillcrest
Great Maple takes brunch seriously, and I mean that as a compliment. We’ve been to the Hillcrest location, and it’s perfect for a slow weekend morning. OC friends: there’s one at Fashion Island in Newport Beach (also lovely) and one at Disney’s Pixar Place Hotel in Anaheim, handy on a Disneyland trip.
Best For: A leisurely brunch · What to Order: Parmesan truffle fries (yes, at brunch) · Thick-cut bacon · Buttermilk pancakes any way · Fried chicken and maple bacon doughnuts · Steak and eggs
Lucrezia – La Jolla (UTC)
We stopped at Lucrezia for lunch on the way to Coronado for Max’s birthday, after seeing it all over Instagram. The covered patio is stunning, and arriving at opening meant a calm start. It’s owned by a Mexico City restaurant group, which gives an Italian menu an interesting lens. The linguine vongole (very lemony, which I love) and the San Daniele pizza were both delicious.
Best For: A beautiful al fresco lunch · What to Order: Calamari fritti · Linguine vongole · San Daniele pizza. Next time: gamberoni alla griglia
Rare Society – University Heights
Rare Society is where you go for something truly indulgent. We celebrated Max’s 29th birthday at the University Heights location, and it reminded me why a great steakhouse is a different experience from a good one. There’s a San Clemente location much closer to home, which we fully intend to make a habit.
Best For: A special-occasion dinner · What to Order: Hamachi crudo · The Associate Board for two (ours had filet, Wagyu tri-tip, and Wagyu Denver) · Asparagus · Whipped potatoes · Butter cake
On My List for Next Time
- Born & Raised, the steakhouse with a reputation that precedes it
- Herb & Wood, Mediterranean-leaning cooking in Little Italy
- Le Coq, French in Bankers Hill
- Leila, Mediterranean in Little Italy
- Marisi, the Little Italy spot that keeps coming up
- Neighborhood, the beloved East Village gastropub
- Seneca Trattoria in Mission Hills
- The Whaling Bar at La Valencia
- VULTURE
Where to Stay Near the Best Restaurants
- The Guild Hotel: Walk to Little Italy. Expedia · Booking.com
- The Granger Hotel: In the Gaslamp, near Rustic Root. Expedia · Booking.com
- The Bower: On Coronado, near Brigantine’s island location; where we stayed for Max’s birthday. Expedia · Booking.com
More in where to stay in San Diego. And if you’d like someone else to plan the eating, a Taste of Little Italy food tour is a fun first afternoon.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is San Diego’s best neighborhood for restaurants?
Little Italy, with Barbusa, Monello, Bencotto, Ironside, Nolita Hall, and Craft & Commerce within a few blocks. The Gaslamp Quarter and the waterfront are close by.
What is the best Italian restaurant in Little Italy, San Diego?
Barbusa for a lively, modern dinner, Monello for build-your-own pasta, and Bencotto for the cheese-wheel pasta experience.
Where should I eat for a special occasion in San Diego?
Rare Society, where we celebrated my husband’s 29th birthday, is a standout steakhouse. Ironside is a beautiful choice for seafood and cocktails.
San Diego’s dining scene has grown so much even since we lived there, and keeping up with it is one of my favorite reasons to drive south. One last thing: yes, a good part of this list is Italian, in Little Italy, no less. If you know me at all, you’re not remotely surprised. Mangia bene!
